What Casting Directors Really Look For in Self-Tapes
If you’re auditioning regularly, chances are you’re self-taping more than ever. But just because it’s common doesn’t mean actors are doing it well. One of the biggest things I hear from both sides of the table—casting and actors—is confusion about what really matters in a self-tape.
Here’s the truth: most actors are focused on the wrong things. Fancy cameras and perfect backdrops don’t book the role. But these things do:
1. Clear, Consistent Eyeline
Who are you talking to? Where are they? If you’re speaking to one person, keep your eyeline consistent and just off-camera. If there are multiple characters in the scene, make sure you establish who is where before you start taping. Wandering eyes or inconsistent eye placement can totally disconnect the viewer from your performance.
If the script is a commercial or direct address piece, you may need to deliver straight to camera—but unless it’s clearly written that way, assume the other character is just off-screen.
2. Dress the Part—But Don't Go Full Costume
Wardrobe should help tell the story without becoming a distraction. Scrubs for a nurse? Great. A lab coat, stethoscope, and bloodied gloves? Probably too much. Think suggestion, not costume. You want casting to picture you in the role, not roll their eyes at overkill.
3. Natural, Grounded Performance
This is probably the biggest factor in getting a callback. Be real. Be grounded. Avoid performing at the camera and instead focus on having a real moment with your imaginary scene partner. Yelling every line doesn’t show intensity—it shows you’re not connected. Get in the head of the character. Feel what they feel. Make them believe it. If your character is angry, you need to be angry too.
A grounded, specific performance will always win out over over-the-top theatrics.
4. Great Lighting and Sound
No, you don’t need a $2,000 setup. But we do need to see and hear you clearly. Use a ring light, soft natural light, or a well-lit room. Avoid shadows and weird color casts. Use a microphone if possible or record in a quiet space. If the viewer is distracted by background noise or can't see your face, you're done before you start.
5. Strong Starts and Clean Finishes
Your first 5 seconds matter. Start in character, take a natural beat, and then begin. Don’t fidget with the camera or slate awkwardly. End the scene cleanly—don’t break character too fast or trail off. A focused beginning and ending help your entire audition feel more professional. Make sure you edit it for self tapes.
Final Thoughts
Knowing what casting directors look for in self-tapes gives you an edge. Take the time to set yourself up for success. Great training, thoughtful choices, and a few key tech upgrades go a long way.
Something to remember- don’t contact them later. Don’t ask for feedback. Do your very best work and move on. Casting is VERY busy and they can’t follow up after auditions unless they need something more from you.
AND- don’t take it personally. If you did your best that is what matters. So many factors come into play with who is chosen for a role, don’t let it get you down. This is a tough industry and full of rejection. You have to enjoy the process and know you did your part, then move on to the next.
If you want personalized help breaking down scenes or coaching your next self-tape, I offer virtual 1:1 coaching tailored to your needs. Reach out here to book a session or ask a question.
